The full-size half-ton pickup truck category is one of the most intensely contested and sought-after classes in America’s automotive market. These vehicles offer a superior combination of power, capability, and adaptability - making them especially attractive to individuals needing vehicles that can do it all. For 2023, three crowd favorites remain the Ford F-150, RAM 1500, and Chevrolet Silverado – each boasting an incredible legacy of dependability & performance while racking up dedicated supporters nationwide. So which pickup reigns supreme? Let us assess every model’s merits against drawbacks to uncover this year’s optimal American big rig!

RELATED: Pick up Truck Drag Race: RAM 1500 TRX vs Ford ROUSH F-150

2023 Ford F-150: $33,695 - $76,775

Black 2019 Ford F-150 Limited
Ford
Front three-quarter shot of the 2019 Ford F-150 Limited being driven on the tarmac

The Ford F-150 is a competent American full-size pickup truck for 2023, offering a wide range of features and performance capabilities to meet your needs. From the powertrain options to its impressive towing capacity and payload ratings, the F-150 can handle whatever challenge.

Under the hood, you have a multitude of engine options ranging from the 290 horsepower 3.3 liter V-6 to the 400 horsepower 5.0 Liter V-8 and even hybrid models that maximize efficiency and fuel economy with up to 700 miles of range from a full tank of gas! With its impressive available torque of 570 pound-feet from the 3.5-liter Hybrid V-6, the Ford F-150 simply can't be beaten in terms of twisting force in the class.

In terms of capability, the F-150 has an impressive maximum towing capacity of 14,000 pounds — besting both the RAM 1500 and Chevrolet Silverado. It also offers payload ratings ranging between 1840 and 2,135 pounds for different configurations. Up to six available 120V/20A points are available in the bed. This makes it ideal for those who want to power tools, need to transport large cargo items, or take on heavy-duty tasks like hauling livestock or construction materials.

Moreover, of the eight available trims, the Ford F-150 offers an interior that is luxuriously equipped, especially with its King Ranch, Platinum, and Limited models. Materials used, throughout the cabin are high quality, and plenty of storage cubbies are present for convenience. Knowing that some may use their F-150 as a mobile workspace, Ford included various features to make life easier. Think of features like the stowable shifter, interior work surface console that can hold a laptop, and lockable storage.

An 8.0-inch infotainment display running on the brand's improved Sync 4 software comes standard, while those looking to upgrade have the option of the larger 12.0-inch display. All in all, the F-150 is designed to create an enjoyable driving experience making it one of America's best full-size pickup trucks.

RELATED: Here's How The Ford F-150 Lightning Stacks Up Against The Rivian R1T

2023 Chevrolet Silverado 1500: $36,300 - $73,395

Blue 2022 Chevrolet Silverado
Chevrolet
A front 3/4 shot of a Chevrolet Silverado High Country

The Chevrolet Silverado 1500 is a robust, reliable full-size pickup truck that can go head-to-head with the Ford F-150 and RAM 1500. Its range of engines offers a maximum towing capacity of 13,300 pounds. The engine lineup includes a 310 horsepower turbo four-cylinder, two V-8 engines, and a 3.0-liter Duramax turbo diesel engine with 495 pound-feet of torque. In addition, the 6.2-liter V-8 engine provides 420 horsepower for spirited driving, while the brakes offer firm and reassuring feedback when needed.

The Silverado has a payload capacity between 1870 and 2280 pounds depending on the powertrain you choose; however, it trails behind the Ford F-150 in terms of max towing capacity. Despite this, the Silverado still offers superior agility and handling ability compared to other trucks in its class due to its lightweight construction. In addition to its impressive powertrain capabilities, it boasts notable features such as an advanced trailer system for increased trailer safety, a multi-camera system for enhanced vision around the truck, and upgraded bed protection features. The Multi-flex tailgate in particular is a highlight of the Silverado.

All these features make the Silverado a strong contender against its rivals when you're shopping around for the best American full-size pickup in 2023. With the Silverado, you get a pickup truck that can be completely tailored to your needs. From its Work Truck base model all the way up to luxury High Country trimming, it offers drivers an impressive interior complete with modern features like 12.3-inch digital gauges and up to a 13.4-inch touchscreen across the nine available trims.

GMs Supercruise hands-free driving system is available for added convenience on long trips — but don't expect too much comfort in the back seats! Though they may not provide plush seating options, this automotive powerhouse makes up for it by delivering ample hauling space plus Multi-Flex tailgate capabilities, so there's no job left undone. So whichever adventure calls: let them come — because The Silverado is ready!

RELATED: 2023 Chevrolet Silverado 1500: Performance, Price, And Photos

2023 RAM 1500: $37,410 - $84,555

2023 Blue Ram 1500 front 3/4
Ram
2023 Blue Ram 1500 front 3/4 view parked in driveway in front of very nice house.

The Ram 1500 is a tough and reliable pickup truck that stands tall among its compatriots. Its 5.7 liter Hemi V-8 engine churns out an impressive 395 horsepower and 410 pound-feet of torque. With its 48-volt hybrid system and eTorque (also offered on the base Pentastar V-6), this powerplant is capable of towing up to 12,750 pounds and carries a payload of 2320 pounds, making it one of America's most muscular full-size pickups.

Furthermore, an available 3.0-liter Ecodiesel engine offers up to 480 pound-feet of torque. The RamBox cargo management system is a highlight of the RAM1500. It offers weatherproof lockable storage. Some trims also offer a dutch door for the bed.

In terms of features and tech, across the eight available trims, the Ram 1500 does not disappoint. This pickup truck offers plenty of driver assistance technology, such as blind spot monitoring and adaptive cruise control with stop/go functionality so drivers can stay safe and comfortable on or off the road. In addition, the interior boasts an Uconnect infotainment system with Apple CarPlay/Android Auto integration and Sirius XM satellite radio, so you can stay connected while on the go.

Overall, the Ram 1500 is the ideal ride for thrill seekers, with its tough exterior and formidable off-roading abilities. Its superior rear suspension system is revolutionary for the class - offering a much smoother ride than other trucks featuring traditional leaf springs, which also makes for the least truck-like driving experience on the pavement. Plus, models equipped with air suspension are customizable to your own preference. With its excellent tow ratings and comfortable ride quality, this pickup easily holds its own against the Ford F-150 and Chevrolet Silverado for the best American full-size pickup in 2023.

RELATED: 2023 Ram 1500: Performance, Price, And Photos

A Definitive Winner:

2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 High Country Review
Photo: Nicolas Sena
Front 3/4 of 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 High Country

With three titans of the pickup truck market vying for the top spot in 2023, it can be challenging to determine which model is best suited for your individual needs. Be it the bed sizes and box sizes available, drivetrain, and available powertrain options, an endless array of configurations are possible across all three models. Dedicated off-road beats in the form of the F-150 Raptor, Silverado ZR2, and RAM TRX are also available for enthusiasts.

However, after an extensive evaluation of all three, it appears that the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 stands out as the most balanced option. Although the Ford F-150 boasts a stellar towing capacity, unlike the Silverado or the RAM there is no diesel option here. The RAM 1500 excels in both comfort and driving experience, while the Silverado is an agile handler with a vast array of powertrains. One weak link for the Chevy is its interior, but the latest model sees a bevy of tech upgrades to close the gap. With that said, when it comes to selecting one truck over another, there is no one-size-fits-all solution; consumers must consider their individual needs before making any decisions.